Best for
- Owners budgeting for insurance who want honest benchmarks, not invented averages
- Anyone who's seen wildly different 'average cost' figures and wants to know which ones are real
- Businesses deciding which policies to buy first
Home / Insurance / Small Business Insurance Cost Guide
Insurance · Updated 2026-10-19
Small Business Insurance Cost Guide
Verified Oct 19, 2026Ask "what does business insurance cost?" and you'll get a dozen confident-sounding averages that disagree with each other. Here's the honest version: no authoritative national average small-business premium exists. Neither the NAIC nor the III publishes one. What does exist: benchmarks the insurers publish about their own customers, and one industry-association range. This page lays out all of it — labeled for what it is — plus what actually moves your price.
How we make money: Unpack Money may receive compensation when you click certain links or apply for products through our site. Compensation may affect where products appear, but it does not determine our editorial evaluations. Learn more
The honest answer: there is no national average
A single average would be meaningless anyway. A freelance graphic designer and a roofing company with twelve employees are both "small businesses," but their risk profiles — and premiums — live on different planets. Any site quoting you one tidy average is either averaging unlike things or inventing the number. We found no NAIC- or III-published national average small-business premium, so we don't present one.
What follows are the figures that do exist, each labeled with exactly what it is: an insurer's published customer benchmark, or an industry association's range. None of them is a quote for your business.
What insurers actually publish
Next Insurance (ERGO NEXT) publishes the most detailed benchmarks on its official cost page: general liability from $19/month (45% of its customers pay $45/month or less); professional liability from $19/month (73% pay $45/month or less); workers' compensation from $14/month (49% pay $75/month or less); commercial property from $18/month (40% pay $45/month or less). These are the company's own customer figures — a reality check, not a promise of your price.
Hiscox publishes one claim: its general liability is "typically $30 a month or less." Again, the company's own figure about its own customers.
The industry range: the Professional Insurance Agents association (PIA) publishes a $500–$3,000 per year range for small business insurance — the only association-level range we found. It's wide because the underlying businesses are wildly different.
What you won't find here: the "$68/month Hartford average" quoted around the web. That figure comes from third-party reporting, not from thehartford.com, so we don't repeat it.
What moves your price up or down
Insurers price risk, and the inputs are mostly things you can reason about:
- Your industry. Roofing costs more to insure than bookkeeping. Physical work, heights, heavy equipment, and customer foot traffic all raise risk.
- Coverage limits and deductibles. Higher limits cost more; higher deductibles cost less — the same dial as every other insurance.
- Payroll and headcount. Workers' comp scales with payroll; liability often scales with revenue or headcount.
- Location. State rules, weather exposure, theft rates, and litigation climates all feed the price.
- Claims history. A clean history earns better pricing; frequent claims do the opposite.
- How you buy. A BOP bundles property, liability, and business income — usually cheaper than buying the three separately.
General liability: the most common first policy
General liability is where most businesses start — it covers third-party bodily injury, property damage, and personal injury (like libel or slander claims) arising from your operations. The published benchmarks cluster in the tens of dollars per month for small, low-risk businesses: Next from $19/month, Hiscox typically $30/month or less. But a contractor with real jobsite exposure will pay multiples of that. The benchmark tells you the floor, not your price.
Workers' comp: priced differently from everything else
Workers' compensation is the odd one out: in nearly every state it's legally required once you have employees (all states but Texas, with employee-count thresholds varying by state), and it's priced largely off payroll by job classification. Next Insurance's published benchmark — from $14/month, with about half its customers at $75/month or less — reflects very small payrolls. A business with a real crew in a high-risk trade will pay far more. Because it's mandatory, the shopping question isn't whether but from whom and at what classification — misclassified job codes are a classic overpayment trap worth checking.
Keeping costs down without creating gaps
The legitimate ways to pay less:
- Bundle into a BOP if you're eligible — property + liability + business income in one package usually beats three separate policies.
- Raise deductibles you could actually pay tomorrow, rather than cutting coverage limits.
- Ask about every discount. Next advertises discounts of up to 25% on some state pages — discounts are often not applied automatically.
- Re-shop annually. Insurers re-price constantly; loyalty is rarely rewarded.
The illegitimate way: buying the cheapest premium without reading exclusions. A policy that excludes your actual work is not cheap — it's decorative. Compare quotes properly before you chase the lowest number.
Key costs, at a glance
| What | Figure | Source |
|---|---|---|
| General liability — published starting price | from $19/month | Next Insurance — official cost page (company's own customer figures) as of 2026-10-19 |
| Professional liability — published starting price | from $19/month | Next Insurance — official cost page (company's own customer figures) as of 2026-10-19 |
| Workers' compensation — published starting price | from $14/month | Next Insurance — official cost page (company's own customer figures) as of 2026-10-19 |
| Commercial property — published starting price | from $18/month | Next Insurance — official cost page (company's own customer figures) as of 2026-10-19 |
| General liability — published customer claim | typically $30/month or less | Hiscox — official site (company's published claim) as of 2026-10-19 |
| Small business insurance — industry range | $500–$3,000/year | Professional Insurance Agents (PIA) — industry-published range as of as cited 2026 |
Averages mask wide state-by-state variation. Your premium depends on your profile, location, and coverage choices.
Who it's best for — and who can skip it
You may not need it if
- Owners who already have quotes — a real quote beats any benchmark
- Businesses with unusual risks (fleets, hazardous work, multiple states) — benchmarks won't reflect your profile
How to compare
- Treat every published figure as a benchmark, never as your quote
- Get quotes for identical coverage from at least three insurers
- Read exclusions before comparing premiums
- Check whether a BOP bundles what you'd buy separately — usually cheaper
- Ask about every discount; many aren't applied automatically
Your next step
Figure out what business insurance you actually need first — the cheapest policy for the wrong coverage is money wasted. Then compare quotes properly when you're ready to buy.
Small Business Insurance Cost Guide FAQs
What is the average cost of small business insurance?
There is no authoritative national average — neither the NAIC nor the III publishes one. The honest figures available: Next Insurance publishes starting prices from $19/month (general liability) on its official cost page, Hiscox says its general liability is typically $30/month or less, and the PIA industry association cites a $500–$3,000/year range. Your price depends on industry, payroll, limits, location, and claims history.
Why do business insurance quotes vary so much?
Because the underlying risks vary enormously. A solo consultant and a contractor with a crew are priced on different universes of risk — industry, payroll, revenue, location, coverage limits, and claims history all move the number. Quotes that aren't for identical coverage aren't comparable at all.
Is it cheaper to pay monthly or annually?
Annual payment sometimes earns a pay-in-full discount, but the bigger lever is what you buy: a BOP bundling property, liability, and business income is usually cheaper than three separate policies. Ask each insurer about payment discounts when you quote.
Does forming an LLC lower my insurance cost?
Not directly. An LLC limits your personal liability for business debts, but it doesn't change the risk profile an insurer prices — your industry, payroll, and claims history do that. You still need insurance; the LLC and the policies protect different things.
Will filing a claim raise my premium?
Often, yes — claims history is a pricing input, and frequent claims can raise premiums or cost you a claims-free discount. That's not a reason to skip legitimate claims, but it is a reason to handle small, affordable losses out of pocket when it makes financial sense.
Sources
Every figure on this page comes from the official source named. We never use aggregator sites as sources.